Top 5 Affordable Collingwood Cards to Invest in for Long-Term Gains

If you’re a Collingwood fan or a savvy trading card investor, knowing which cards to buy, grade, and hold can pay off significantly in the long run. Collingwood has produced some of the AFL’s biggest stars, and their cards—especially rookie and graded versions—can see strong appreciation over time. Below, we break down the best players to invest in, how to find their cards at reasonable prices, and why grading them is key to maximizing your return.

1. Nathan Buckley - Collingwood Legend & AFL Great

A Brownlow Medalist and one of Collingwood’s most celebrated players, Nathan Buckley’s cards remain in high demand among collectors. His 1994 Select Rookie Card is a standout for investment purposes.

• Best Card to Target: 1994 Select Nathan Buckley Rookie Card

• Why Invest? One of Collingwood’s all-time greats, Buckley’s legacy keeps his cards relevant.

• Investment Strategy: Buy raw in good condition, grade it through PSA or SGC, and hold for long-term appreciation.

2. Peter Daicos - The Macedonian Marvel

A Magpies icon and father of current stars Nick and Josh Daicos, Peter Daicos remains a fan favorite. His vintage cards continue to gain traction among AFL collectors.

• Best Card to Target: 1981 Scanlens Peter Daicos Rookie Card

• Why Invest? With his sons making waves at Collingwood, nostalgia and demand for Peter Daicos cards remain strong.

• Investment Strategy: Look for raw cards on eBay, check condition thoroughly, get them graded, and hold as demand increases.

3. Scott Pendlebury - The Timeless Leader

Pendlebury’s impact on Collingwood is undeniable, and his longevity in the game makes his cards a strong long-term investment.

• Best Card to Target: 2007 Select Rookie Card

• Why Invest? A multiple-time premiership player, Collingwood captain, future Hall of Famer, and one of the AFL’s most consistent and all time great midfielders.

• Investment Strategy: Opt for raw rookie cards in mint condition, grade them, and hold for his post-career hype.

4. Dane Swan - Brownlow Medalist & Magpies Icon

A superstar of the 2010 premiership team, Swan’s popularity among Collingwood fans ensures steady demand for his cards.

• Best Card to Target: 2004 Select Rookie Card

• Why Invest? Brownlow Medal winners often hold strong value, and Swan remains a fan favorite.

• Investment Strategy: Acquire affordable raw copies, get them graded, and sell once the AFL nostalgia market increases his value.

5. Nick Daicos - The Future Superstar

Nick Daicos is already making waves, and his rookie cards are among the hottest in the AFL market right now.

• Best Card to Target: 2022 Select Rising Star

• Why Invest? Already one of the best young players in the league, his long career ahead means strong growth potential.

• Investment Strategy: Buy and grade while prices are still reasonable, then hold for the peak of his career.

Grading & Holding Strategy for Maximum Value

Investing in raw cards and getting them graded is the best way to increase their value. Here’s the step-by-step process:

1. Buy Raw Cards on eBay – Look for listings with clear images and descriptions mentioning minimal surface damage.

2. Inspect the Card – Use a magnifying glass and inspection light to check centering, edges, and surface quality.

3. Send for Grading – PSA, SGC, or BGS are the top choices for AFL cards. Higher grades (9-10) dramatically increase resale value.

4. Hold for Peak Market Interest – Wait for milestones like Hall of Fame inductions, retirements, or major AFL events before selling.

Where to Buy & Sell Collingwood Cards

• Best Marketplace for Buying: Check Collingwood Cards on eBay Now 

• Best Place to Sell: eBay, Facebook trading groups, and local card shows.

By following this strategy, you can turn your passion for Collingwood and AFL cards into a profitable investment. Whether you're holding onto vintage legends like Buckley and Daicos or betting on the future of Nick Daicos, grading and patience will be your best allies.