Follow us!

Get in touch with us

Item has been added

Top 5 Investment-Worthy Fantasy Trading Card Sets

  • person Gareth Fraser
  • calendar_today
Top 5 Investment-Worthy Fantasy Trading Card Sets

1. Magic: The Gathering – Alpha (1993)

  • Why It's Investment-Worthy: The Alpha set kicked off the entire trading card game industry. With only around 2.6 million cards printed, these early MTG cards — especially the Power Nine (like Black Lotus) — are holy grails for collectors.

  • Key Cards: Black Lotus, Ancestral Recall, Time Walk.

  • Long-Term Outlook: Extremely strong. Graded Alpha cards in good condition can fetch six figures.

2. Flesh and Blood – Welcome to Rathe (2019)

  • Why It's Investment-Worthy: Flesh and Blood burst onto the scene with high-end artwork, strategic gameplay, and a growing global player base. Cold Foil cards from the early sets are already commanding premium prices.

  • Key Cards: Fabled cards like Heart of Fyendal.

  • Long-Term Outlook: Strong, with print-run transparency building long-term trust.

3. Pokémon TCG – Base Set (1999)

  • Why It's Investment-Worthy: Though not pure "fantasy" like medieval fantasy, Pokémon's world-building qualifies for many. Base Set Charizards, Blastoises, and Venusaurs are now cultural icons.

  • Key Cards: Charizard (1st Edition, Shadowless).

  • Long-Term Outlook: Steady. Nostalgia and global brand strength keep demand high.

4. Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (Magic Crossover, 2023)

  • Why It's Investment-Worthy: This Magic x LOTR set shattered expectations, especially with serialized "The One Ring" (1/1 copy found by Post Malone!). Non-serialized chase cards and serialized Sol Rings are still very hot commodities.

  • Key Cards: The One Ring (Special Edition), Serialized Sol Rings.

  • Long-Term Outlook: Moderate to strong, especially for serialized and premium variants.

5. MetaZoo – Cryptid Nation (1st Edition, 2021)

  • Why It's Investment-Worthy: MetaZoo taps into cryptid mythology (Bigfoot, Mothman, etc.) with vintage card design appeal. It's very polarizing but has a loyal following. 1st Edition booster boxes have spiked hard since launch.

  • Key Cards: Mothman (Holo 1st Edition).

  • Long-Term Outlook: High-risk, high-reward. If the brand grows, early prints could become goldmines.


Bonus Tips for Investing:

  • Grade Early: Send key cards to PSA, CGC, or BGS early before pops rise.

  • Sealed is King: Keeping booster boxes sealed often outperforms single cards over time.

  • Chase Rarities: Always focus on serialized, foil, or special art variants.

  • Patience Wins: Fantasy TCG investing often pays off after 5+ years, not overnight.