Tips and Tricks for Getting Higher Grades with PSA

As a devoted PSA-reviewed card collector for several years, I have submitted countless trading cards for evaluation. Over time, I’ve developed a list of tips and tricks to help increase the odds of receiving higher grades when sending your cards to PSA. While these methods cannot guarantee success, they have worked well for me, resulting in numerous PSA 10 Gem Mint returns from my submissions.

Disclaimer: These tips are meant to provide guidance and spark discussion. I cannot guarantee their effectiveness, but feel free to share your own suggestions in the comments below!

Inspect Your Cards Under Magnifying Light

PSA utilizes advanced technology to detect flaws such as re-shading, surface scratches, reprints, fake signatures, and improper cutting. To inspect your cards on par with PSA’s standards, you’ll need tools like:

• A jeweler’s loupe

• A black light

• A magnifying light

These tools are especially valuable if you plan to invest heavily in the hobby and submit a large number of cards each year. Here are some key qualities of high-graded PSA cards:

• Four Perfectly Sharp Corners: Ensure there are no visible dings or bends.

• Sharp Focus: Images should be clear and non-blurry.

• Free of Staining: Avoid fingerprints, water stains, or sunspots.

• Proper Centering (Front): Centering should not exceed 55/45 to 60/40.

• Proper Centering (Back): Centering should not exceed 75/25.

• Minor Print Imperfections: Minimize visible print defects.

Use Brand New Penny Sleeves and Card Savers

Always use fresh penny sleeves and card savers for your submissions. Here’s why:

1. Improved Presentation: Old sleeves may be stained or sticky, potentially transferring dirt or residue to your card.

2. Prevention of Fingerprints: New sleeves help reduce the risk of smudges during handling.

3. Positive Impression: When graders remove your card, the pristine condition of the sleeve creates a professional impression.

Penny sleeves are cost-effective, typically priced at just a penny each. Replacing old or oversized sleeves is a small investment that can lead to significant rewards. For cards purchased online or in stores, always replace their sleeves—even if you’re not planning to have them graded immediately.

Clean Your Trading Cards Before Submitting

While it may seem like common sense, card cleanliness is often overlooked. Graders do not clean your cards; they evaluate them as-is. If your card arrives dirty, it will be graded lower due to surface imperfections.

To maximize your card’s potential:

1. Inspect for Dirt or Smudges: Look for any visible grime or fingerprints.

2. Use Proper Cleaning Techniques: Carefully clean the surface using safe and approved methods.

Spending a few minutes cleaning your cards at home could be the difference between a lower grade and a higher one. For a step-by-step guide on cleaning trading cards, check out this video tutorial.

Conclusion

While there are no guarantees in achieving higher grades with PSA, following these tips can significantly improve your chances. The key is attention to detail—inspect your cards thoroughly, use new sleeves, and ensure they are clean before submitting them for grading. With a little extra effort, you’ll be well on your way to achieving those coveted Gem Mint returns.

Do you have any additional tips for preparing cards for PSA grading? Share them in the comments below—let’s learn from each other!